Last month I went to this regional archaeological museum like an hour-and-a-half away from me with my one (former) assisted living client with (disabilities), and the exhibits were surprisingly good, and then at the very end of the museum there was a mention that like decades ago they had gotten a major grant from a major national public grant-giving body to create this one super-cool major exhibit hall.
And, that made me so happy, because that's a great use of public funds, but it also made me flash back to this prof who I had studied with years ago when I was doing my Ph.D. -- she turned out to be the second faculty bully who went after me -- and, later after I graduated, I came across a social media dust-up where she had secured a grant from that same grant-giving body for some big historiography review where she summoned handpicked people to fly in from across the country for multiple seminars and discussions on her field and where it's going, and then in her ultimate write-up she held up 1 of 2 books as a punching bag, but she just cited one book's title (?!) without looking at what it said inside the covers, even at major junctures like the introduction (?!), and it actually did everything she said that it didn't, and in a really obvious way, too.
Which is nuts, since this wasn't some random book she added in as a last minute citation, but 1 of 2 books she held up as representative of bad trends in her field -- the topic of the entire grant-funded project! -- and she didn't know on a very, very basic level what was going on with this book that was supposedly so important to her thinking and perspective.
Which is kind of what she had done twice during the end of my doctoral process when she went nuts, and before I could extricate myself from her grasp.
And, as I myself determined and as was confirmed with a mentor who went over the texts with me, that's totally research misconduct that's way beyond the boundaries of normal professional behavior --- this wasn't misunderstanding a text because you were reading through with one thing in mind and not another, or maybe missing a more-developed form of an idea that was tucked away at the end of an unimportant chapter, this was just citing a book's f*cking title without even trying to know the basics of what was in it...
I mean, if that was acceptable academic behavior, anyone could cite nothing but book titles and pillory ideas and approaches that the books actually do, and then claim those ideas and approaches for themselves to come out on top, and everyone would come away glowing and being all like, "Oh, you're so smart!".
Like, that behavior wouldn't be acceptable from a college freshman, let alone from somebody who's supposedly at the top of their field.
Anyhoo, that just p*ssed me off... What a waste of money, that money for her historiography project could have gone to stuff like museum exhibit overhauls like the great one at that museum, but noooo, she signed up to take on a project where she didn't even bother to deliver the major basic deliverable at just a very basic minimal level of quality.
What narcissistic behavior, and what unchecked anti-social behavior.
The only reason to get a grant like that and not deliver is if you're that self-absorbed and high on your own bullshit, i.e. a heightened form of a common mentality among "the tenured."